critical thinking and problem solving: adding strategic value to your F&A role.

Let's break down what critical thinking truly means within the context of finance. It's the capacity to analyze information – be it financial statements, market trends, or regulatory changes – with a discerning eye. It involves asking pertinent questions such as:

• what are the underlying assumptions?
• is the data reliable and relevant?
• are there alternative interpretations?
• what are the potential consequences of different actions?

Critical thinking in finance isn't about being negative or finding fault; it's about striving for clarity, accuracy, and a deeper understanding of complex financial scenarios. It's about moving beyond the surface level and exploring the 'why' behind the figures. 

Despite the rapid and widespread adoption of AI in finance—where 88% of US companies are using it, and 62% to a moderate or large extent—a 2024 KPMG global report highlights that critical thinking remains a highly valued core skill in the sector.

On the other hand, problem-solving—closely linked to critical thinking—is the process of identifying issues, analyzing their root causes, and developing effective solutions. In finance, this could involve addressing a dip in profitability, navigating cash flow challenges, or optimizing tax strategies. Strong problem-solving skills, underpinned by critical thinking, allow you to approach these challenges systematically and creatively, rather than just applying standard procedures.

In the competitive US business environment, critical thinking skills are not just advantageous – they are increasingly vital finance skills. Consider the sheer volume of financial data you encounter daily. Without the ability to critically evaluate this information, you risk being overwhelmed by noise and potentially missing crucial signals that could impact your organization's financial health.

Furthermore, the regulatory landscape in the US is constantly evolving. Keeping abreast of these changes and understanding their implications requires a critical and analytical approach. While AI can ensure compliance and mitigate superficial risks, it is you who needs to be able to interpret new legislation, assess its impact on your company, and devise appropriate data-driven strategies for compliance.

According to the Future of Jobs Report 2025 commissioned by the World Economic Forum, critical and analytical thinking are still consistently ranked among the top skills that employers are looking for. This underscores the growing recognition that professionals who can think critically and solve complex problems are invaluable assets to any organization, particularly within the intricate world of finance.

The raw numbers in a financial report tell a story, but it's your critical thinking that allows you to decipher the narrative. With AI and ML becoming increasingly popular, you can also leverage these technologies to clear out irrelevant data, while using your innately human cognitive skills to prioritize what matters:

• identify trends and anomalies: By critically examining financial data over time, you can spot significant patterns or unusual deviations that warrant further investigation. For instance, a sudden spike in operating expenses might indicate inefficiencies or potential fraud.
• assess financial health: Critical thinking enables you to go beyond basic ratios and truly understand the underlying financial stability and performance of the company. This involves analyzing liquidity, solvency, profitability, and efficiency metrics in a holistic and interconnected manner.
• evaluate investment opportunities: When considering potential investments, critical thinking allows you to assess the associated risks and rewards objectively, scrutinizing financial projections and market analysis with a healthy degree of skepticism.
• improve risk management: By critically analyzing financial data and potential scenarios, you can identify potential risks early on and develop proactive mitigation strategies, safeguarding the organization's financial well-being.

Financial modeling, planning, and forecasting are crucial tools for strategic decision-making. However, the accuracy and reliability of these tools heavily depend on the critical thinking applied in their development and interpretation.

• challenging assumptions: A critical thinker will constantly question the underlying assumptions built into financial models. Are these assumptions realistic given the current market conditions in the US? What are the potential sensitivities if these assumptions prove to be incorrect?
• scenario planning: By applying critical thinking, you can develop various scenarios – best-case, worst-case, and most likely – to understand the potential range of outcomes and prepare accordingly. This involves considering different economic conditions, market shifts, and internal factors.
• evaluating model outputs: It's not enough to simply generate a financial forecast. Critical thinking allows you to assess the plausibility of the results, identify any inconsistencies, and understand the key drivers behind the projections.

Research from AMA highlights that companies with superior forecasting capabilities often outperform their competitors. This advantage is not solely due to sophisticated software, or artificial intelligence, but rather the sharp analytical minds that drive the forecasting process.

Want to boost your critical thinking for your finance role? Here’s how:

techniques to integrate:

• five whys: The "Five Whys" is a systematic problem-solving technique that involves repeatedly asking "Why?" to uncover the root cause of a financial anomaly. By drilling down through multiple layers of causation, you move beyond surface-level symptoms to understand the fundamental underlying issues that are driving unexpected financial patterns or challenges.
• structured argumentation: Structured argumentation involves building recommendations through a rigorous, logical framework that relies on concrete evidence and clear reasoning. This approach ensures that financial insights and proposals are not based on intuition alone, but are supported by data, clear chain of logic, and verifiable information that can withstand critical scrutiny.
• scenario planning: Scenario planning is a strategic analysis method that involves creating multiple plausible future scenarios to help organisations prepare for different potential outcomes. By developing comprehensive "what-if" models, financial analysts can anticipate potential risks, identify strategic opportunities, and design flexible response strategies that can adapt to various potential economic or market conditions.
• peer review & debate: Peer review and debate are critical processes that involve subjecting financial analysis to rigorous examination by colleagues and experts. This approach helps challenge underlying assumptions, identify potential blind spots, and refine analytical conclusions through constructive criticism and diverse perspectives, ultimately leading to more robust and well-considered financial insights.

formal learning and development:

• critical thinking courses: Explore options from reputable universities or professional development organizations.
• analytical finance diplomas: Consider advanced qualifications from the ACCA or CIMA with modules focused on strategic analysis.
• data analysis training: Upskill in tools like Power BI or Tableau.
• problem-solving workshops: Participate in focused workshops offered by professional development bodies.

active engagement and practice:

• case study analysis: Deconstruct financial cases from sources like the Harvard Business Review.
• cross-functional projects: Collaborate with other departments for diverse perspectives.
• mentorship: Seek guidance from experienced finance professionals known for their analytical skills. Engage in regular one-on-one sessions focusing on their problem-solving approaches and decision-making frameworks. Also look for mentorship programs within your organization or professional networks.
• seminars and webinars: Attend industry seminars and webinars focused on financial analysis and strategic thinking. Organizations like the CFA (Chartered Financial Analyst) Institute or local AICPA (American Institute of Certified Public Accountants) chapters frequently host events covering advanced analytical techniques. Keep an eye on their event calendar for relevant sessions.

By actively using these techniques, pursuing targeted learning, and engaging with experienced mentors and relevant seminars, you'll actively sharpen your critical thinking abilities in the US finance sector.

The true value of critical thinking and problem-solving lies in their practical application. Here are some examples of how these skills can make a tangible difference in your F&A role:

• identifying cost-saving opportunities: By critically analyzing expenditure patterns, you might identify areas where efficiencies can be improved without compromising quality or strategic objectives. For example, a thorough review of supplier contracts could reveal opportunities for negotiation and cost reduction.
• improving budgeting processes: Critical thinking can help you move beyond simply repeating past budgets and instead develop more realistic and strategically aligned financial plans that reflect the current business environment and future goals.
• navigating regulatory changes: When new US financial regulations are introduced, your critical thinking skills will be essential in interpreting the requirements, assessing the impact on your organization, and developing effective compliance strategies.
• presenting financial information effectively: Being able to critically analyze financial data allows you to extract the most relevant insights and communicate them clearly and concisely to non-financial stakeholders, supporting informed decision-making across the organization.

conclusion.

Cultivating robust critical thinking and problem-solving abilities is no longer a supplementary skill for finance and accounting professionals in the US – it's the bedrock of adding genuine strategic value. By moving beyond routine tasks and embracing a more analytical and inquisitive mindset, you position yourself as a vital contributor to your organization's success in a dynamic and complex economic landscape. The power to discern, evaluate, and solve is your key to unlocking greater influence and impact within the finance function!

FAQs